Discussion about this post

User's avatar
F.B. Fanat's avatar

Well written, Vanya, it must have taken you some heart to publish this one. There's lots I would comment here, but I'd rather you and I share thoughts on these topics over a drink some day. As someone who lived through a war on my doorstep very much like what's happenining now in Ukraine, it filled me with a deep sadness from the day it started, not just the destruction and the killing, but because I've seen what it does to people's souls.

But I'll mention one thing - you write about objective truths and universal human values. I used to think these things are real, but I don't anymore. There's nothing objective in the idea one shouldn't kill. At best it's "don't kill members of the same tribe", to keep social order, but the Other can be slaughtered and enslaved. The belief that the Other deserves rights is a comparatevly new and, I've come to realize, very fragile idea that tends to slip away easily under a bit of pressure. And if you want to turn people on each other, all you have to do is convice someone that another is an Other and watch as they rationalize how destroying the Other is what makes one Good. So yes, a world where this doesn't happend needs to be earned indeed, and the work is long, hard and ungreatful. And requires a lot vigilance.

Expand full comment
Dane Benko's avatar

Very important work at a very important time in history — when "checking yourself" and your values is harder than it's portrayed in just-so literature and forces larger than yourself are always shifting the moral landscape beneath you step by step.

Expand full comment
12 more comments...

No posts